Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

When it comes to bluegill, how old is "old"?

I posed the question to biologist Daryl Bauer what qualifies as an old bluegill, and asked if he had sampled some really ancient specimens in his years as a fisheries professional.

Here was my question.

"Actually, I'd like to know from Daryl if he's seen any truly ancient bluegill in his sampling days. You know, like 12 or 13 year old fish. I've probably aged, or assisted in aging somewhere around or over 200 bluegill, but haven't run across any real oldies like that yet.

An interesting point is that in a given population, a ten year old fish isn't necessarily going to weigh more than an eight year old fish. Sometimes the fish begin to regress, or go "geriatric" and the weights drop back a little".


His answer was as follows.

"I do not know how many fish, bluegills included, I have aged. I am sure it would be in the thousands. In addition we have an age and growth database of thousands and thousands of fish we have aged in Nebraska. We have documented bluegills up to age 13 from Nebraska waters. Ancient bluegills are possible, but not at all common. In fact in many waters it is rare to see bluegills older than age-6.

Now let me say something about aging fish, especially aging old fish. Fish to some extent have indeterminate growth--they continue to grow throughout their lives. Yes, there are some genetic limits, you are not going to have a 50-pound bluegill, sorry to you and "OldBaldGuy" about that, but fish can grow throughout their lives. As they grow their bony structures grow and the growth patterns in those bony structures are how we age fish. Scales are the most commonly used bony structure used to age fish. However, the older fish get the more difficult it is to achieve an accurate age determination from scales. Scales can erode over time and the older a fish gets the slower it grows; those are a couple of reasons it is difficult to determine the exact age of old fish from scale samples. For most bluegill populations, populations with relatively fast growth and few ancient fish, "reading scales" would be accurate enough to determine age and growth rates needed to make management decisions.

But if you rely solely on scales for aging you might underestimate the age of the oldest fish. If you want to know maximum age, then otoliths (i.e. ear "bones") are probably the best bony structure to use. The thing with aging fish by using otoliths is the fish have to be sacrificed and there is some prep. work and additional techniques to be mastered to "read" otoliths. "Reading" scales is relatively quick and easy compared to "reading" otoliths and the fish aged from a scale sample can still be swimming. I said all of that to say this, we may underestimate the oldest bluegills out there because we do not look at as many otoliths as we do scales.

You are absolutely right on your last point--the oldest fish may not necessarily be the biggest. In fact if I wanted to find the oldest bluegill I could, I would look for a population of relatively slow-growing fish. A population of small, stunted bluegills might be more likely to have some "ancient" fish than a population of fat & happy fast-growers. As a general rule in fish populations, fish from populations with slower growth rates will live longer than fish from populations with fast growth rates. That is one reason I continue to insist that big fish are not necessarily as old as one might believe. Big fish might get that way because they are fast-growers and not necessarily just old. That is why catch & release of big fish, big bluegills especially, can be so important--those are likely fast-growers and some of the best genetic stock.

You are also right that the very oldest fish may actually "regress" towards the end of their life. Fish can grow throughout their life, but growth rates slow the older a fish gets. They may "plateau" at some point where they really do not grow any longer for the rest of their life. Big fish that reach that "plateau" may continue to be healthy and may put on weight, but their lengths may increase very little if at all. Naturally as fish age they eventually reach a point where they just wear out, their condition and weight begins to decline, but their length does not shrink; eventually they die."

Views: 147

Comment

You need to be a member of Bluegill - Big Bluegill to add comments!

Join Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Comment by David Merical on October 10, 2008 at 8:42am
I'd noticed similar trends from fish sampling results here in Iowa. Older fish often times were SHORTER than some large younger fish. It made me think they might shrink when they get older, but apparently this isn't the case, just a misinterpretation of the data.

Latest Activity

David, aka, "McScruff" replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Jig Fishing Under A Float.....Things to Consider and Other Recommendations
"Randall, Streamers and hackle flies work best on jigs. Flip em upside down and tie a Wooly Bugger on the hook. I secure the tip of the hackle an eye length ahead of the hook barb, so the palmered hackle is clear of the hook gape and increases in…"
15 seconds ago
John Sheehan commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Tabbert Pond Oct 24th

"Sounds great ! Bee wanting to try peanut oil .Have you tried  that before Dick?"
20 minutes ago
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Tabbert Pond Oct 24th

"John well cook them in hot oil. I filleted then and cut them into pieces. Got about 6 big bags of fillets. Next step is that hot oil."
31 minutes ago
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Panfish all release

"Thanks John. All the pan fish were turned back next year will be keeping some perch for the table."
34 minutes ago
Ken Sobanski commented on Ken Sobanski's photo
35 minutes ago
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Panfish all release

"Thanks Ken and we are pleased. We going to concentrate on the gills now we all want monsters."
35 minutes ago
John Sheehan commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Tabbert Pond Oct 24th

"Excellent , how ya gonna cook them? That 29" go ten pounds?"
59 minutes ago
John Sheehan commented on Ken Sobanski's photo
1 hour ago
John Sheehan commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Panfish all release

"Nice Dick and Cheyenne !I like that 13 " Perch!"
1 hour ago
Tony Livingston commented on LedHed's photo
Thumbnail

IMG_1353

"The low water levels I've been seeing in photos are, to be honest, terrifying to me. I hope that things turn around out there, and soon. I'm just watching from afar, yet it's still upsetting to me. I can hardly imagine what you guys…"
1 hour ago
Ken Sobanski commented on LedHed's photo
Thumbnail

better chunk

"Nice fish! hey do you guys ever step foot on dry land!"
1 hour ago
LedHed commented on Ken Sobanski's photo
Thumbnail

20141024_161356—BFOTD 13” CLASS PERCH-CPR

"WOW - excellent - congrats on the CPR"
1 hour ago
Ken Sobanski commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Panfish all release

"Dick and Cheyenne it looks you efforts are really paying off!"
1 hour ago
LedHed commented on LedHed's photo
Thumbnail

IMG_1386

"LOL - you guys make me laugh. Like this chunky female Hybrid - they fight hard. Fishing in 40 FOW."
1 hour ago
LedHed commented on LedHed's photo
Thumbnail

better chunk

"Thnx guys Bellyspinners and chubs Jim - had to really move though. Weird pattern, lot of migrating going on right now. Level is still dropping - hopping I don't have to move the boat. Glad I was able to get Matt on some good BGs. No toads but I…"
1 hour ago
Ken Sobanski commented on Ken Sobanski's photo
Thumbnail

20141024_161356—BFOTD 13” CLASS PERCH-CPR

"thanks guys... this hen came out of a 47 acre sized lake. released it so it could release millions of eggs next spring."
1 hour ago
LedHed commented on LedHed's photo
Thumbnail

IMG_1353

"Enjoy you analogy with the meat - makes sense. You don't know what your missing until you try it.... Our surface water is in the low 70s - more worried about the level right now. Not easy staying on top of seasonal moving fish. If I…"
1 hour ago
Ken Sobanski commented on Bruce Condello's photo
Thumbnail

P1020583 (2)

"just looked on Amazon.com their not listed yet! "
2 hours ago
Ken Sobanski commented on Bruce Condello's photo
Thumbnail

P1020583 (2)

"awesome shirts... need one so i can post some pics on crappie.com .... lol"
2 hours ago
carl hendrix commented on Bruce Condello's photo
Thumbnail

P1020583 (2)

"yep;; WE  NEED SHIRTS!!!     AWSOME SIZE GILLS TO BRUCE!!"
2 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Bluegill.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service